Google+

What Counts as Tenant Damage in New Zealand?

Damage is one of the most common questions we get from both owners and tenants. The rules are set by the Residential Tenancies Act. Who pays depends on how the damage happened.

Fair wear and tear

Fair wear and tear is not tenant damage. It is the gradual decline that comes from normal day-to-day living, such as carpet wearing thin in a hallway, faded curtains or minor scuffs on walls.

The owner is responsible for keeping the property in a reasonable state of repair, and these costs sit with them.

Careless damage during a tenancy

Careless damage happens when a tenant doesn’t take reasonable care. Leaving a pot on the stove unattended or letting a bath overflow are common examples.

Tenants are responsible for careless damage caused by them or their guests, but the amount is capped. They pay the owner’s insurance excess or four weeks’ rent, whichever is lower.

This is why every tenancy agreement must state the property’s insurance excess.

Accidental damage during a tenancy

Accidental damage is caused by the tenant but is outside their control, such as tripping and putting a knee through a wall.

If the damage is genuinely accidental and not careless, the tenant is not liable. The owner covers the repair, either directly or, through their insurance, including the excess.

In one Tenancy Tribunal case, a tenant knocked over a hot iron and melted the carpet. The Tribunal ruled it accidental, so the tenant paid nothing.

The line between careless and accidental isn’t always clear. When the two sides can’t agree, the Tenancy Tribunal decides.

Intentional damage during a tenancy

If a tenant or their guest damages the property on purpose, the tenant is liable for the full cost of repairs. There is no cap on the amount in damages.

The same applies when damage comes from an act that is an imprisonable offence.

Pet damage during a tenancy

Since 1 December 2025, tenants are responsible for all pet-related damage beyond fair wear and tear, with no cap. Owners can also charge a pet bond of up to two weeks’ rent to help mitigate damage caused by a pet.

Who has to prove what

If a damage claim goes to the Tenancy Tribunal, the owner must show the damage happened during the tenancy and isn’t fair wear and tear. The tenant then needs to show it wasn’t careless or intentional damage.

Why records matter

A detailed ingoing inspection with photos is the best protection for both landlords and tenants. It shows exactly what the property looked like on day one. That makes the difference between wear and tear and damage much easier to settle.

At Home & Co, we complete thorough ingoing, routine and outgoing inspections on every property we manage. If you own a rental in Wānaka, Albert Town or Lake Hāwea, we are happy to talk through how we protect your investment. Call 03 443 2273 or email rent@homeandco.co.nz.